The gift of silence
Here is one quote, one question and one idea to contemplate.
"The right word may be effective, but no word was ever as effective as a rightly timed pause."
– Mark Twain
How could you offer the gift of silence with your team?
Have you ever sat in a meeting and wondered whether your silence was helping or hurting the conversation? Was it a thoughtful pause, allowing ideas to take shape, or an uncomfortable void where words should have been?
Silence in the workplace is a double-edged sword. In Chapter 8 of my book Understood: The greatest human need and the key to engagement, I discuss how silence can be a gift—a space for reflection, deep thinking, and processing. Or, it can be a roadblock—an unspoken barrier to progress, innovation, and trust. Appreciating the difference between productive and unproductive silence is key to fostering an engaged, high-performing workplace where people feel understood.
Productive Silence: The Power of Reflection
Productive silence is intentional. It is the quiet moment before responding, the thoughtful pause that allows for deeper engagement. It happens when a leader asks an open-ended question and gives the team time to think before answering. It’s the silence that invites a hesitant voice into the conversation, making space for insights that might otherwise go unheard.
In high-quality workplace conversations, productive silence allows individuals to process ideas, listen with full attention, and generate thoughtful responses. It cultivates psychological safety—the belief that speaking up will be met with respect and curiosity rather than judgment. When employees feel safe to contribute, they become more engaged, creative, and committed.
Unproductive Silence: The Cost of Withholding
On the other hand, unproductive silence stems from fear, uncertainty, or disengagement. It happens when employees hesitate to speak up because they fear criticism, rejection, or wasting time. It’s the silence in a meeting where team members hold back ideas, assuming their input isn’t valued. It’s the unspoken tension that arises when difficult topics go undiscussed, leading to frustration and misalignment.
Research shows that organizations suffer when people withhold information. A lack of open dialogue can lead to poor decision-making, missed opportunities, and low morale. If silence becomes the default, innovation stalls, and trust erodes.
Creating a Culture of Thoughtful Silence
As leaders we play a crucial role in harnessing the power of silence effectively. To do so, consider:
promoting deep thinking by creating intentional pauses during discussions to allow people time to process and respond;
giving space for others’ thoughts without rushing to fill the silence to show that what team members have to say is valued;
encouraging quieter team members to contribute by providing structured avenues for input, such as written reflections, to invite all perspectives; and
being explicit that speaking up is not only welcome but expected reinforcing that constructive dialogue leads to better outcomes.
Silence, when used well, is not empty—it is full of possibility. Productive silence leads to productive workplaces where people feel safe to engage in both thoughtful pauses and open dialogue. In this space, we foster understanding and feeling understood.
Until next time,
Maria
P.S. If this has been helpful, then feel free to pass it along to someone else who might enjoy it too.
‘UNDERSTOOD: The Greatest Human Need and the Key to Engagement’
AVAILABLE NOW!
MARIA’S 2025 WORKSHOPS
Foster greater understanding and workplace engagement through this series of new workshops. Learn more about them by clicking on the titles below:
If you’d like to get one or more of these in your team or Board’s calendar, let’s connect.
WOULD YOU LIKE TO EXPLORE…
why we struggle to understand others
the roots and impacts of misunderstanding
the art of understanding others
strategies to foster understanding and advance engagement
Sign up below to have the UNDERSTOOD video mini-series sent directly to your inbox.
READY TO ELEVATE YOUR WORKPLACE ENGAGEMENT?
Let’s talk about how I can help you elevate engagement and drive organizational performance, so that you can move beyond chasing engagement metrics and start leading them!